First things first… long time member of the Cup family Chuck Grigsby headed off to Bulgaria (not quite Zaire, but close) for a fight this last weekend and walked away (well, we hope) with a victory. If you are new to the column, Chuck has been an MMA (Mixed Martial Arts) style cage fighter for a couple years now and this is his first international fight. He fought on Saturday as a light heavyweight against Atanas Dzhambazov (9-1/93 kg/204.6 lbs.). The Chuckster (17-4/93 kg/204.6 lbs.) was able to pull off the victory with a three-round unanimous decision! Congratulations and, as always with you Chuck, you are most defiantly THE MAN!
www.m-1global.com/en/news/detail/id/9138/m-1-challenge-bulgaria-results
Brian Hibbs, Superhero of retailing!…
Comicbookresources.com has another Tilting at Windmills article up by Brian Hibbs of the Comic Experience in San Francisco. This month’s talks about the ComicsPRO meeting in Memphis recently.
I like Hibbs for a lot of reasons. One, he successfully sued Marvel comics and two, he is hated by Diamond. For those two reasons alone, he practically walks on water.
This latest column mentions when ComicsPRO group going on a tour of the new Diamond facility. The one replacing the Memphis facility where we got our direct and reorder shipments from. He really nails the irritation over the last two months from a retailer’s perspective. Here is an excerpt:
“Walking into the warehouse really is like the final scene in “Raiders of the Lost Ark,” this huge facility stretching back out to your visual vanishing point. A few words on [the switch]: Diamond pretty much catastrophically screwed the pooch for reorders in February – the move from their old facility to this new one went wrong in just about every way possible.”
So, if you think I’ve been making up stories to deflect blame, the comic Messiah has spoken and it is the truth! Thanks Brian. To read the rest of this month’s Tilting at Windmills you can find it here: www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=20595
Hockey goon gets five minutes for fighting…
Last week I, the bully of our story, tried to pick a fight, mostly with my business partner Curt on the matter of Geoff Johns, but several of you jumped up to the challenge instead. — kind of like George Larauqe last year when everyone tried to pick on little sissy boy Cindy Crosby, but I digress.
To recap, I have been feeling Johns has lost his ability to write new and different (read that as good) superhero narratives lately. To sum up my comments from last week (and many a week before) I feel he retreads too much on older writers ideas and changes stuff for the sake of change, not something I like to see from any writer, but especially one with actual talent.
However, enough from my punk ass. This is what some of you had to say:
Chad credits Johns with getting him into Green Lantern and Jonah said that he had utter disdain for the Green Lantern, until the regular series and Johns’s writing brought him into it. Jonah goes so far as to call him one of the best superhero writers in the industry. Both will be buying the Flash: Rebirth series (which comes out this week!) and Jonah would like a Johns-esque Aquaman: Rebirth and Martian Manhunter one as well. (Well, Johns is going to do that to Marty, but not really like you were thinking. Stay tuned to one of the books you are currently reading. I know what is planed, but am not saying.)
Mike, who helps me every other Wednesday with books, is a very a big Johns fan and said it was I who got him to start reading his stuff in the first place. “I recall being a some what new member to the Cup Clan and I still wasn’t reading a whole lot of titles at the time. But one day when I was in the shop, Big Poppa Cup (Matt) said “Dude (yes I do believe at the time he was saying dude) you’ve got to read the Flash it is AWESOME!!!” To which I gave my patented response, “But ‘dude’ it’s the Flash.” At which time Matt
said, “But this new guy is writing him, his name is Geoff Johns and he is AWESOME and he has made the Flash even more AWESOME!!!”
Mike probably exaggerates, I would never (as I adjust my monocle) call anyone “dude.” He continues saying I got him to suggest Green Lantern as well and now he reads and loves it, because of the Johns writing alone. He counters my argument of Johns falling behind on his story telling quality by saying “…I don’t think this was Johns’ fault. Marvel and DC both do this to good writers.” They throw money at them and put them on every book, because of dollar signs.
I think Mike is probably right on about this. I probably am a little harsh in some of my criticism when it comes to the big writers, due to their being stretched too thin. When you just work on one thing and focus solely on that one thing, you will be good at it. Juggle fifteen things and you’ll drop something for sure. However, if you are an artist (writer), shouldn’t that weigh in? Maybe yes, maybe no.
Allen H. chimed in and I think unknowingly supports the argument in saying “Johns was at his best when he wrote the Flash. Now he writes everything to set up stories in the future like Clairmont used to do on X-Men. When he leaves a title, the next writer has to tie up too much stuff.” This is sort-of is my point when I compare him to John Byrne. My god, the poor sap who is going to take over JSA or even what happens to Tomasi on Green Lantern Corp. I personally enjoy GL Corp more then GL because of the characters (hates the Hal), but sometimes it really seems like the story is dictated in from story notes.
There was one person who wrote in to help me out. In hockey terms it would have been called ‘third man in’ and he would have gotten in or around 15 minutes of penalties, possibly ejected from the game and maybe a league suspension, but his disgust with DC has NO bounds. Joe used to read a bunch of just DC books, but now refers to his dwindling pile as his “weekly disappointment.”
About Flash: Rebirth he had this to say, “Barry has been gone for close to 25 years. He had his run. How much will current readership care about his return? For myself and many other readers, Wally West has grown into the role of the Flash and is our Flash. The Flash is a legacy character. If they could create a new Flash and make him compelling, I’d be more interested honestly.”
Is this what the fans want to see or what Geoff Johns wants to see? The same could be said for what he did to Kyle Rayner during Green Lantern: Rebirth.
Joe goes on to ask about continuity of the speedsters including Max Mercury or how Bart was used, aged and killed when none of that worked. Joe says that “Barry fans beware of when the next editor or writer gets bored and he is phased out.”
He continues with an excellent little rant about Dan Didio, bringing Barry back, the terribleness of Identity Crisis (and I would add by extension, the neverending crossover that led to Johns’s horrible Infinite Crisis) and how, nearly none of this works with what has come before and even what they are trying to do now. He ends by saying “I really know how the Pre-Crisis on Infinite Earths fans felt… The rug has been pulled out from under me.”
If Joe will let me I’ll post his comments on the website. You can also find the longer and better written comments under last week’s post from Jonah.
I guess to sum up, I’ve probably been to harsh. He is a good writer, but when he gets the praise for bringing back a character who doesn’t need to be brought back or messing up a bunch of continuity (or just throwing it out), it makes me mad. He is still lauded as the god of DC… and this happens while a great writer goes nearly unnoticed over on X-Factor, writing one of, if not their best book. That writer is Peter David. I guess I just don’t like someone, and Johns fits this to a tee, getting to comfy and they should be challenged to do better then they are currently doing.
and… Because Johns is pretty much the anointed one at DC, those of us who consider these “our” characters turn our anger against the heads of the company when we feel slighted by the decisions that change the company we were supporting long before they got any critical (Wizard) or financial praise (big money crossovers).
Also, always know, these are, as almost everyone who wrote in said, merely my opinion. I’m just trying to spark discussion… and occasionally a fight.
On that note… lets tar and feather Brain Bendis…
I have an article for your consideration. Pat, the X-collector, brought a blog post to my attention this week that implies Brian Bendis hates women or at the very least has some serious issues. Neither he or I agree with it entirely, but it is interesting, to say the least. Here is the post:
cbddossiers.blogspot.com/2007/06/record-brian-michael-bendis.html
...and the two of us were, off the top of our heads, putting together a list of other stuff the article doesn’t mention, like: Tigra v. The Hood, when Dr. Doom actually called Ms. Marvel a whore, Norman Osborne shooting the queen skrull in the head, Spider-women is hated by everyone due to skrull queenie running around as her, Wasp killed, New Avengers #47 where a female skrull is shot in the head by a SHIELD agent before even revealing info, all the Scarlet Witch stuff in Disassembled and finally, Sentry ripping off Morgan le Fay’s head in Dark Avengers… WOW! WTF?!? Pat puts it best by saying, “If Bendis doesn’t hate women he sure isn’t helping his case.” What do you think? I have to say, I think….